Are Asphalt Shingles Right for Your Commercial Roof?

When considering roofing options for a commercial building, the choices can seem overwhelming. From metal panels to membrane systems, the variety of materials available today is extensive. One often overlooked yet surprisingly versatile option is asphalt shingles. While more commonly associated with residential homes, asphalt shingles for commercial roofs are growing in popularity—especially for low-slope and steep-slope structures on smaller commercial buildings. In this blog, we’ll explore whether asphalt shingles are the right fit for your commercial property, comparing them to other materials, outlining pros and cons, and examining their long-term value.

Understanding Asphalt Shingles in a Commercial Context

Asphalt shingles are composed of either an organic or fiberglass base that is saturated with asphalt and coated with ceramic granules. Their design allows for a range of aesthetic finishes, from rustic to contemporary. Traditionally, asphalt shingles have been a mainstay in residential construction because of their cost-effectiveness and ease of installation. However, when it comes to commercial properties, the decision to use asphalt shingles depends on a few critical factors: building design, regional climate, maintenance expectations, and cost considerations.

For commercial buildings with sloped roofs—such as retail centers, office complexes, apartment buildings, and small churches—asphalt shingles can be a practical choice. Their adaptability and visual appeal offer more than just surface-level value. In areas where budget constraints are important and roof pitch allows, asphalt shingles provide a balance of performance and affordability that few other roofing options can match.

Advantages of Asphalt Shingles for Commercial Roofs

One of the strongest cases for using asphalt shingles for commercial roofs is their low installation and material cost. Asphalt shingles remain among the most affordable roofing materials on the market, making them especially attractive for budget-conscious property managers or developers. Compared to options like metal or tile, asphalt shingle systems can reduce upfront roofing expenses by a significant margin.

Another notable benefit is their ease of installation and repair. Roofing contractors are almost universally familiar with asphalt shingles, which translates to shorter project timelines and reduced labor costs. In addition, if a section of the roof becomes damaged due to wind or hail, it’s relatively simple and cost-effective to replace a few shingles instead of re-roofing large areas.

Versatility is another key advantage. Asphalt shingles come in a wide array of colors and styles, allowing commercial building owners to align the roof’s appearance with branding, neighborhood aesthetics, or architectural goals. Some premium shingles can even mimic higher-end materials like slate or wood shakes at a fraction of the price.

From a maintenance perspective, asphalt shingles generally perform well in a range of environments. While not as long-lasting as some premium materials, they can still provide 20–30 years of reliable protection when properly installed and maintained. Many modern shingles also feature built-in resistance to algae, fire, and UV rays, increasing their resilience over time.

Disadvantages and Limitations of Asphalt Shingles

Despite their benefits, asphalt shingles are not a one-size-fits-all solution. One of the main limitations is their incompatibility with flat or low-slope commercial roofs. These roofing systems require a watertight membrane—such as EPDM, TPO, or modified bitumen—that can withstand standing water. Asphalt shingles rely on gravity to shed water effectively, making them unsuitable for slopes less than 2:12.

Durability is another concern, especially in harsh weather environments. While impact-resistant shingles exist, standard asphalt shingles can be vulnerable to hail, wind uplift, and temperature fluctuations. In regions with severe storms, hurricanes, or extreme freeze-thaw cycles, building owners might find themselves repairing or replacing shingles more frequently than anticipated.

Lifespan is also an important consideration. While 20–30 years is a reasonable expectation under optimal conditions, other commercial roofing options—such as metal or single-ply membrane systems—can offer lifespans of 40 years or more with proper care. If long-term performance is a priority and budgets allow, it may be worth exploring alternatives.

Finally, asphalt shingles are petroleum-based products, which raises environmental concerns. Though some manufacturers now offer recyclable or more eco-friendly options, asphalt shingles still lag behind materials like metal or green roofs in terms of sustainability and environmental impact.

Comparing Asphalt Shingles to Other Commercial Roofing Options

To truly evaluate whether asphalt shingles are the best roofing for commercial materials buildings, it’s helpful to compare them to some of the more common commercial roofing systems.

TPO and EPDM membranes are popular for flat or low-slope commercial roofs. They offer excellent resistance to weather, punctures, and UV exposure, and they provide a seamless waterproof barrier. However, their installation is more complex and usually comes with a higher upfront cost than shingles. These systems also require specialized labor and are less visually appealing for sloped roofs that are visible from the ground.

Metal roofing is another contender, especially for buildings that require long-term durability and minimal maintenance. Metal panels can last 40–70 years, resist wind and fire, and are highly recyclable. The trade-off is cost—both in materials and labor—and the potential for noise issues during rain or hail, unless properly insulated.

Clay or concrete tiles offer outstanding aesthetics and longevity but are heavy and expensive. These are rarely used on commercial properties unless there is a specific architectural vision driving the decision. The structural requirements to support tile roofs also limit their application.

Modified bitumen and built-up roofing systems (BUR) are excellent for flat roofs but are often overkill for smaller sloped structures. They provide high durability and resistance to foot traffic and weather but can be cost-prohibitive for certain budgets and less flexible in terms of visual design.

In contrast, asphalt shingles occupy a unique space. For commercial properties with a pitched roof and moderate environmental demands, they deliver a solid middle ground. When comparing performance per dollar spent, shingles often outperform more expensive materials on small to medium-sized commercial buildings.

When Are Asphalt Shingles the Best Choice?

Ultimately, the decision to use asphalt shingles for commercial roofs depends on a variety of building-specific factors. Asphalt shingles are best suited for commercial properties with a steep or moderate slope, modest square footage, and tight budget constraints. These might include professional offices, clinics, apartment buildings, strip malls, and smaller religious institutions.

They also make sense in regions with relatively mild climates, where the risk of severe wind or hail is minimal. In such cases, shingles can offer a dependable, attractive, and budget-friendly solution that meets the functional and aesthetic needs of the property.

On the other hand, if your commercial roof is flat or frequently exposed to severe weather, you may want to invest in more robust systems like metal or membrane roofing. These materials, while more expensive upfront, provide enhanced protection and longevity in demanding conditions.

If sustainability is a top priority for your business, metal roofing or green roofs may align better with your environmental goals. However, premium asphalt shingles that incorporate recycled content or are part of manufacturer recycling programs can still be a viable eco-conscious alternative.

Choosing the best roofing for commercial materials buildings is ultimately a balancing act between cost, performance, maintenance, aesthetics, and environmental impact. Consulting with a qualified roofing contractor or commercial building consultant can help you evaluate options specific to your building’s design and location.

Conclusion

Asphalt shingles for commercial roofs are a compelling option when conditions align—particularly for pitched roofs on smaller commercial structures with budget constraints. While they may not be the universal answer for every building type, they represent a versatile, cost-effective solution in the right circumstances.

Need a Roofing Company in Springfield, MA?

Since 1987, R & H Roofing has remained one of the most trusted names in the roofing industry. We specialize in commercial and industrial roofing and offer a wide variety of roofing systems including EPDM systems, TPO Systems, Metal Roofing Systems, BUR Tar & Gravel Systems, Asphalt Shingles, and PVC Systems. We also work with some of the leading manufacturers including Firestone, Carlisle, Duro-last, and Garland. Contact us today to learn more about what we can do for you!

Categorised in: Commercial Roofing

This post was written by admin